Monday, 28 January 2013

Taylor, Bates and the future of keeping

Ashley Giles' first move as England's white ball supremo, or at least the first that cannot be cloaked in the fog of rotation, has been to ditch a keeper in favour of a county team-mate who is second-choice with the gloves back at home. "It has been slightly awkward," admitted Jos Buttler, gamely.

Choices on tour are limited, and Kieswetter's abject form left him with little credit in his account but it feels like a pivotal time for the position itself, so secure in the Test side, so fluid everywhere else.

It's a matter of philosophy, the future of keeping in the post-Gilchrist era, and Giles appears to be thinking quite conventionally about it. Someone like Butler is the acme of this approach, a guy who is essentially a batsman with a second string to his bow. England have a raft of them that they can argue over, from Bairstow to Kieswetter, while they apparently lack the desire to solve the conundrum of their one true thoroughbred, Matt Prior.

But, as this blog has long held, 50 over cricket is dead; it just hasn't finished threshing about on the hook yet. It's in the T20 game that Giles' approach will have longer term implications, and there's an emerging argument (well from me at least) that a complete reappraisal of the wicketkeeper's role is coming.

Like Duckworth Lewis, it's simply an equation of resources. T20 is a game for specialisation, because unlike Test and ODI cricket, those resources are rarely exhausted in the time allocated.

The maths goes something like this: at the start of each game, the wicketkeeper is the only specialist position guaranteed to be able to affect a minimum of 50 per cent of the match while using their primary skill (the 20 overs for which they keep). A bowler has ten per cent (four of 40 overs), the two opening batsmen an unlikely maximum of 50 per cent, the other batters a sliding downward scale from there.

Accepting that almost everyone can field well, and that all-rounders increase their overall percentages by batting and bowling, it's easy to see that the most valuable player in these simple terms of opportunity would be an opening bat that can bowl (Chris Gayle, perhaps), although the occasions on which even the transcendent Jamaican carries his bat occur infrequently.

The wicketkeeping position can therefore be reimagined as an attacking option for a fielding side. It's an opportunity to reduce the effectiveness of the batsman by keeping him in his crease against seam bowling, thus reducing his scoring options. While it's hard to quantify exactly how many runs might be saved by a gloveman capable of standing up to the seamers, it is a move that would challenge many of the techniques of T20 batting. It might not be fanciful to guess that the score might be limited by 20-30 per innings, at least until batsmen adjusted in turn.

It first suggested itself in the performance of Michael Bates in the CB40 final last season. It's easy to go into some kind of reverie when watching him keep; he brings back memories of Bob Taylor standing up to Ian Botham, of the impish skills of Knott, the silken hands of Russell. Hampshire have choked many a side with a combination of skiddy medium pace, spin and Bates behind the dollies.

Taylor, Knott and Russell were a different shape to the gym-produced, identikit bodies that burst forth from the tight-shirted present. The demands of the job mitigate against the physique needed for power hitting, and a specialist keeper might have to be regarded a little like a bowler, with his main contribution coming in the field. But without running the stats, it would be interesting to know how often the seventh batter in a line-up has done the job when six others couldn't.

Bates is an obvious choice for Giles and England. A less immediate but nonetheless intriguing selection for a county side might be Sarah Taylor. She is lithe and athletic, attributes that are evident in her keeping. The debate about her lack of power as a batter has rather blindsided the fact that it is motor skill and movement, rather than strength, that make a great wicketkeeper. It's in circumstances like these, a short game where a single skill can have a disproportionate effect, that a cricketer like Taylor might one day fit.


44 comments:

Sri lanka Holidays said...

Good Post

Anonymous said...

"...the most valuable player in these simple terms of opportunity would be an opening bat that can bowl"

This is another reason why Shane Watson is God amongst men in T20 while a bad commodity in Tests.

Clipping Path Service said...

Nice Blog. Actually Taylor is always good player. I think he is best.

Scott Oliver said...

Fascinating post, and an interesting way of approaching the impact of w/k's in T20, but perhaps the quantification of players' involvement may be misleading or too simplified. As ever, it's what you do in the time involved.

Also, the higher the level of cricket, the greater will be the speed of the bowlers, the less likely it will be that the w/k can stand up to the entire attack, or that it would be advantageous to do so (missing thick-edged catches, possible byes). And quite how a keeper would keep his eyes on the ball with Dilscoops and ramps being played would also be interesting...

Russell stood up at Bristol partly because it was a slow pitch and none of the bowlers were tall AND quick, and I think the necessity for specialized keepers will to a certain extent be indexed to the weapons in the attack, perhaps the conditions.

Brian Carpenter said...

Excellent and thought-provoking as always, OB.

As for the reverie, yes, I've been there (the day after the CB40 Final, in fact).

Much more will be heard of Bates, and it's to be hoped that it doesn't entirely depend on him improving his batting.

Anonymous said...

thanks for share..

Jack Sheldon said...

Very interesting blog, although I'm not sure I agree entirely.

I know that the focus of your arguments is T20s rather than ODIs (which, incidentally, I feel will be around for some time to come, and rightly so).

However, I'll say a few words about ODIs first: in that format, unless the best gloveman happens to bat 1-6 or you have a plethora of world-class all-rounders, I don't see how you can pick him. All recent empirical evidence suggests that players at the top of the order that can make 100s, followed by destructive 'finishers' to take advantage of the last 15 and then 5 specialist bowlers (+ a reliable safety valve) is the most successful structure. There is no room for a non-batting 'keeper in that, particularly if, like Bates, they aren't aggressive.

On to T20 it perhaps becomes more of a subjective issue. Certainly, I don't think you want to have a poor/ part-time 'keeper (e.g. Umar Akmal and arguably Bairstow) who is likely to miss lots of chances. However, I don't think that the difference between a Bates and a Buttler is quite as wide as you are suggesting. Whilst Buttler may not have effected the win in the CB40 final quite as Bates did, that situation where one bit of 'keeping changes the course of the game occurs in perhaps 1 in 20 matches. Does that one-off situation justify the loss of runs? I wouldn't have thought so. I'd argue that Buttler is perfectly competent enough to take 95% of the regulation catches and stumpings (even Foster misses a few)and to take his fair share of non-regulation ones too. For me, that is good enough and the best utilisation of resources.

The Old Batsman said...

Scott and Jack, yes I do agree to an extent. It's more about trying it out, and then finding some much better evidence of how many runs a keeper can save. I don't have the time or the stats knowledge to do that, but Hants have been extremely successful in T20 cricket without having an explosive 200+ team, and Bates has been a big part of that.

Unknown said...

Jobs at your Home, Internet Online Jobs like data entry, copy pasting, Form Filling, Facebook Sharing Jobs, Clicking Jobs, Web Surfing, Google Jobs and Much More Earning Systems Online
www.jobzcorner.com

King Cricket said...

I've only just seen this. I made a similar point six years ago, but I think you make it more persuasively. I like the cold logic of breaking down the percentage of the game that can be influenced, in particular.

For what it's worth, this was my piece.

http://www.kingcricket.co.uk/twenty20-wicketkeeping/2008/01/09/

I like to keep my writing half-arsed to prevent fully formed thoughts from being expressed.

Clipping Path said...

Really Awesome Blog Thanks for Sharing..

clipping path said...

So amazing.

Background Removal said...

Background Removal Services (BRS) is one of the best Clipping path service provider around the world. We offer our global customers: Raster to Vector Services, Photo Restoration Services Prices, Photo Neck Joint Service, Exposure Color Correction Service, Jewelry Photo, Retouching Services, Photo Color Correction Service, Image Mirror Effect Service, Cheap Retouching Services, Deep Etching Service,

Anonymous said...

A Best Hand Held Massager is smalleror cheaper than another doesn’t necessarily mean it’s less effective, it just means it’s designed with another purpose in mind. The first thing you should know about self-massage tools isthat they come in many shapes, sizes, and price ranges. Just because

Mason said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
photo touch up said...

useful and effective post you have made . So much thanks for this shared .

background remove said...

Wonder story! Thanks for the great information about Taylor, Bates and the future of keeping.

Pankaj Singh said...

Thank you so much, I got valuable information for me. I need this information past some time, visit ogen infosystem for the best website designing and digital marketing services.
Web Designing Company

sachin said...

gmp certification in delhi
halal certification in delhi
ce certification in delhi
iso 13485 certification in delhi
website designing services
seo serivces in delhi

sachin said...

Bali Honeymoon Packages From Delhi
Bali Honeymoon Packages From Chennai
Hong Kong Packages From Delhi
Europe Packages from Delhi
Bali Honeymoon Packages From Bangalore
Bali Honeymoon Packages From Mumbai
Maldives Honeymoon Packages From Bangalore
travel company in Delhi

sachin said...

we have provide the best fridge repair service.
fridge repair in faridabad
Videocon Fridge Repair in Faridabad
Whirlpool Fridge Repair in Faridabad
Hitachi Fridge Repair In Faridabad
Washing Machine Repair in Noida
godrej washing machine repair in noida
whirlpool Washing Machine Repair in Noida
IFB washing Machine Repair in Noida
LG Washing Machine Repair in Noida

sachin said...

we have provide the best ppc service.
ppc company in gurgaon
website designing company in Gurgaon
PPC company in Noida
seo company in gurgaon
PPC company in Mumbai
PPC company in Chandigarh

sachin said...

Rice Bags Manufacturers
Pouch Manufacturers
wall putty bag manufacturers
Lyrics with music

The Corporate Gift said...

Thank you so much for sharing such an amazing blog with us, keep it up for more updates about this related blog. Visit Thecorporategift for Corporate Gift Ideas and Corporate Diwali Gift.
Corporate Diwali Gift

Mutual Fundwala said...

Awesome blog, thank you so much for sharing such an amazing blog with us. Visit Mutual fundwala for Mutual Fund Companies, Mutual Funds India and Best Performing Mutual Fund.
Mutual Fund Companies

UFO3D said...

https://ufo3d.com

Clipping path service said...

Excellent write-up and wonderful descriptions. Your post is very helpful for me. A big thanks for sharing !!
Clipping Path
Clipping Images

Clipping Path said...



Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic blog post.

Buy Viagra online said...


Erectile dysfunction or impotence is a health issue that is suffered by men. In this problem, the man becomes unable to get the perfect erection. Irregular blood flow in the body is the cause of this problem. This problem may happen because of various reasons. By taking the help of smart drugs, this problem can be solved. Viagra 150 mg is very effective as an ED pill. Viagra is a brand version of Sildenafil which is a PDE5 inhibitor. It cannot cure your ED, but when you take it with proper sexual arousal, and then it can help you in getting the perfect erection. This ED pill you can easily find in the market. Buy Viagra online and thus you can get this ED pill at an affordable price. There are lots of benefits you can enjoy if you buy Viagra online.
Buy Viagra online

Pradeep Appslure said...

Great post! I really enjoyed reading it. Keep sharing such articles. Looking forward to learn more from you.
Mobile app development company in mumbai

nahar said...




Chitta Kurta Karan Aujla and Gurlez Akhtar

For all Punjabi music fans, check-out latest Punjabi song ‘Chitta Kurta’ sung by Karan Aujla and Gurlez Akhtar and music is given by Deep Jandu. Watch the video to know more about song . Check out Etimes Punjabi music videos section for more Punjabi songs, Karan Aujla New song, Gurlez Akhtar songs, and other Punjabi latest songs.

chita kurta karan aujla mp3 download

chitta kurta karan aujla mp3

chitta kurta karan aujla song download

chitta kurta karan aujla mp3 download

chitta kurta by karan aujla mp3 download

chitta kurta karan aujla

chitta kurta karan aujla mp3 song download

karan aujla chita kurta song download

karan aujla new song chitta kurta download

Chitta Kurta Latest Punjabi Song By Karan Aujla


Azad soch punjabi news
punjabi newspaper

punjabi newspaper

punjabi Epaper

atharveducation said...

The School of Distance Education and Learning is affiliated under Jaipur National University, Rajasthan, and was established in the year 2008-2009. Being gloriously approved by DEC and accorded by the Joint Committee of AICTE-UGC-DEC in September 2009, the School of Distance Education and Learning started its spectacular journey in providing state-of-the-art educational programs at both under-graduate and post-graduate levels that are under the moderation of Jaipur National University.
jaipur national university distance education contact number
jaipur national university distance education study center
jaipur university distance mba
jaipur national university distance education result
jaipur national university distance education review

Being a member of the Association of Indian Universities (AIU), the programs are recognized by WES. Students may verify the same from the WES platform for Canadian Immigration. NMIMS Distance Education program serves its students with highly innovative and revolutionary technology and offers every digital solution to enable faster and most tactful learning process to its students.
nmims ngasce
mba wx nmims
mba wx nmims
nmims certificate courses
nmims correspondence mba

India is a land that has observed constant and exhaustive changes in the educational pattern across all examination boards. The multitude of changes has always been aimed towards the rapid growth and development of students so that they can nurture and thrive into highly established professionals in the industry.
dy patil distance learning.com
dy patil open distance learning
dy patil distance education courses
dy patil distance learning
dy patil distance mba

datriyo said...

The Network Systems Engineer must document all the interactions with detail technical descriptions, root causes and solutions. The professionals have to examine and evaluate the new technology and must brief others about its merits, weaknesses and recommendation on adoptability. They have to validate the updates of the operating system, software, hardware.

globalonlinepills said...

Body pain is a very common issue that we have to face in our daily life. When you face the issue of pain, it is best if you take the help of the doctor. But every time, you cannot get the help of the doctor. In those situations, to get quick and effective relief from pain, you take the help of the painkillers. Soma pill is an effective painkiller by using which you can get instant relief from your pain. This painkiller has Carisoprodol as the active ingredient. You can buy Soma 350 easily from the market. To enjoy the effects of this painkiller at an affordable price, buy Soma 350 mg online.
Buy Soma 350mg pills Online
Soma 350mg
soma 350mg tablets
soma 350mg dosage

We all have across some or the other body pain at some point in life. Certain body ache can be so severe that it can affect the normal functioning of the person. Therefore to be able to work and function well the person needs to take some kind of medication. The pain medicine that is widely used and accepted by people all across is the use of Soma pill. It is effective in treating a number of body pain caused by different factors. So buy soma pill online to get rid of any kind of body pain to have a pain free and healthy life.
Buy Soma 500mg pills Online
soma 500mg
soma 500mg tablets
soma 500mg dosage

When you feel any kind of body pain, it is best if you go to the doctor for treating it. Sometimes body pain can be the symptom of some serious disease. Sometimes body pain attacks us suddenly because of which you may not able to get the help of the doctor.
Buy tramadol hcl 50mg
tramadol 50mg
tramadol 50mg tablets
tramadol 50mg dosage

Pain is a sensation that is unpleasant and can affect the normal functioning of the person. Now no one would like to suffer from any kind of body ache but it is also not possible to avoid such cases in life. Sometimes the body pain can become so serve that it can come in the way of the daily functioning of the person.
Buy tramadol hcl 100mg
tramadol 100mg
tramadol 100mg tablets
tramadol 100mg dosage

Document Services said...

Thanks for provide great informatic and looking beautiful blog, really nice required information & the things i never imagined and i would request, wright more blog and blog post like that for us. Thanks you once agian
we offer services delhi birth certificate which inculde name add in birth certificate and birth certificate correction complete process is online and we offer
birth certificate and we offer this birth certificate online same service offers at yourdoorstep at birth certificate in ghaziabad our dream to provide birth certificate in india and other staes like birth certificate in bengaluru and birth certificate in gurgaon book service with us birth certificate in noida also, service at yoursdoorstep only birth certificate in india or

Techcloud said...

Wow, pretty cool sharing. I really appreciate your post. I’m working on a different image post-production platform for my image editing work. Anyways very good sharing; please keep sharing more. I’ll definitely visit your blog again. image post-production

Clipping Path View said...

That's a great post. Thank you so much for it from ecommerce photo editing service provider

professional photo retouching service said...

This is very informative post. Thanks for sharing.
Photo Retouching Services

Qater said...

here you can get more info about Allama Iqbal open university result data and student ID process, application tracking, BA Admission
Allama iqbal open university

km346 said...

Hi I am from Join Pak Navy I and I really like your work thanks for this information and keep it up you are doing good

Biddut Sarkar said...

Wow, pretty cool tips. I really appreciate your post. I definitely visit this blog again
Image Post-production Service

munroe island said...

Superb article and valuable information because it’s really helpful for me, Thank you so much for share this wonderful information with us.
best houseboat tours in kerala

CRM software said...

I am following your blog for the last 2 years, your content is informative. please keep sharing your blog.

The client relationship management software assists companies in a lot of ways. It keeps its eyes on vital prospects and manages every sales endeavor. The SalezShark Georgia CRM Software lets you manage your social networking profiles efficiently.

Bangalore Escort said...

Nagarbhavi Escorts
Marathahalli Escorts
Malleswaram Escorts
Majestic Escorts