Saturday 21 June 2014

Sam Robson and the rush to judgment

Geoffrey Boycott was on radio commentary when Sam Robson went to his first Test match hundred. It was an interesting moment because Boycott, in common with almost every expert pundit, had been dubious of Robson's credentials at Lord's. In fairness it was hard not to be: the lad had a horror of a match with the bat, and looked almost as adrift as Simon Kerrigan had with the ball at the Oval last Summer.

Before the applause for Robson had died down, Boycott was asked about his grip, left hand high on the handle, right hand low.

'I don't look at all that, how he holds the bat, whether he picks it up over gully, I just watch his feet, his head and where the ball goes.'

Geoffrey went into a long reverie about technique, taking in Bradman, who had brought the bat down to the ball in a semi-circle - 'no-one's done it since, but he did alright' - and then George Hirst, who had arrived at the Headingley nets from Kirkheaton and immediately started slogging the ball into the rugby club grand stand.

'Now then lad, tha better stop that...' said the coach.

'Look where the ball is...' replied Hirst.

'Everyone's different aren't they,' Boycott went on. 'The good players find their own way.'

It tied in with something I've been thinking about for a while, probably since I blogged this about the golf coach John Jacobs, and the wisdom of sixty years that he had distilled into a single sentence: 'you can tell everything you need to know about the golf swing from watching where the ball goes'.

This, especially in batting's new age, is surely becoming the defining criteria in coaching. The game and its methods are now too diverse to begin from anywhere else. Yesterday, West Indies needed to chase 93 in the fourth innings of their Test against New Zealand and Chris Gayle scored 80 of them from 46 deliveries, walking at the bowlers and baseball-batting consecutive sixes out of the ground from somewhere near the middle of the pitch. 'Look where the ball is,' you could almost hear him say.

England's new intake are symptomatic. Robson has a laundry-list of quirks from a low crouch and heavy head to that odd grip; Gary Ballance plays from so deep in his ground he's often driving with his front foot just past the popping crease; Chris Jordan's decelerating run-up is one of the great mysteries of modern times. Plunkett, who is almost new, has had to reinvent himself having been ruined by the era of bio-mechanics. Only Moeen Ali wears the air of a classicist.

As a credo, 'look where the ball is' means something else too, and that's not to rush to judgment. As poor as Robson appeared at Lord's, he has a Test hundred a few days later. Neither should have too much weight attached to them. Robson hasn't yet offered enough for there to be certainty as to whether he'll make it as a Test opener. If I had to, I would guess that he'll fall short against better bowlers than Sri Lanka's, when his methods get pushed out to their limits, but then I might well have been one of the idiots telling Bradman to bring his bat down straight too. For a while, we'll just look at where the ball ends up.

There is a wider point to be made about the mixed bag that is the nation's top five, and it it comes down to watchability. Cook, Robson, Ballance and Root are an offbeat combo of unspectacular grinders and/or accumulators, with only Bell to break them up. They won't empty bars, and they won't necessarily sell tickets either. It seems odd to say so, but there may be a commercial dimension to their future prospects.

14 comments:

Unknown said...

pepsi ipl 8 2015 live match streaming youtube
pepsi ipl 8 2015 live match streaming free
pepsi ipl 8 2015 matches highlights
pepsi ipl 8 2015 live telecast
ipl 8 live streaming 2015 hd
ipl 8 live streaming 2015 gocricket
ipl 8 live streaming 2015 webcric
pepsi ipl 8 2015 match schedule
ipl 8 2015 live streaming blogspot
watch ipl 8 2015 live streaming online
ipl 8 2015 live streaming low bandwidth
watch ipl 8 2015 live streaming free


fathers day quotes gift ideas 2015
hapy fathers day quotes gift ideas 2015
fathers day quotes gift ideas
fathers day quotes 2015
fathers day quotes In Hindi
fathers day quotes gift ideas 2015
homemade father's day gift ideas
homemade father's day gift ideas from toddler



fathers day poems 2015
fathers day poems
fathers day poems 2015 in spanish from daughter
father's day poems 2015 australia
fathers day poems from daughter
fathers day poems from son
fathers day poems In hindi
fathers day poems In english

Unknown said...

samosir island
tourist north sumatra
white crater indonesia
sumatra travel
sumatra tours travel
north sumatra
anda sumatra
anda sumatra
anda sumatra
anda sumatra
anda sumatra
sumatra travel
tourist places in north sumatra
tourist places in north sumatra
young
grand mosque medan
tourist places in north sumatra
tourist places in north sumatra
tourist
tourist
sky
medan
rohan
bundlr
medan
travel
medan
medan
medan
medan
samosir island
samosir island
samosir island
samosir island
sumatra tours
sumatra travel
gunung leuser national park

Unknown said...

SeruJudi/
BeritaJudi
UnikJudi
PokerPow99
RumahJudi
InfoJudi
atmpoker
reviewbandar
setiadimartinus

Kirk Mathis said...

Agen Poker Online

Poker Online Indonesia

Agen Poker Online Indonesia

Agen Poker Online Terpercaya

Agen Poker Online

Agen Judi Online Terpercaya

Poker Online Terpercaya

Situs Poker Online Terbaru

Unknown said...

Agen Poker Online

Poker Online Indonesia

Agen Poker Online Indonesia

Agen Poker Online Terpercaya

Agen Poker Online

Agen Judi Online Terpercaya

Poker Online Terpercaya

Situs Poker Online Terbaru

Brandi Maldonado said...

Poker Online Terbaru

Poker Online Indonesia

Agen Poker Online Indonesia

Agen Poker Online

Agen Judi Online Terpercaya

Agen Judi Online

Agen Poker Online Terpercaya

Situs Poker Online Terbaru

Poker Online Terpercaya

Agen Poker Online Terbaru

Jermaine Colon said...

Poker Online Terbaru

Agen Poker Online Indonesia

Poker Online Indonesia

Agen Judi Online Terpercaya

Agen Poker Online

Agen Poker Online Terpercaya

Situs Poker Online Terbaru

">Agen Poker Online Terbaru

Poker Online Terpercaya

Roman Knight said...

Poker Online Terbaru

Agen Poker Online Indonesia

Poker Online Indonesia

Agen Judi Online Terpercaya

Agen Poker Online

Agen Poker Online Terpercaya

Situs Poker Online Terbaru

Agen Poker Online Terbaru

Poker Online Terpercaya

essay writing service said...

Very useful information for people, I think this is what everyone needs.

write my paper for me said...

I love reading your articles. Thank you very much. Write more.

homework help said...

Many thanks for this post, this is what I need, I will definitely try.

iphongthuy.net said...


iphongthuynet
iphongthuynet
iphongthuynet
iphongthuynet
iphongthuynet
iphongthuynet
iphongthuynet
iphongthuynet
iphongthuynet

Best Packers and Movers in Hyderabad said...

Looking for professional and licensed verified Packers and Movers at an affordable cost?
Your search ends here... Hire the most licensed and verified packers and movers at an affordable cost and save money, compare the quotes with the top 3 competitors and choose the best one!
100% Licensed & verified Transporters in India

Packers and Movers India | Licensed Transporters | Hassle-free relocation
Call now : 8886663106

Packers and Movers Bangalore
Packers and Movers Vizag
Movers and Packers in Kolkata
Packers and Movers in Mumbai


Bangalore Escorts said...

Hyderabad Escorts
Noida Escorts
Jaipur Escorts
Pune Escorts