Friday, 25 October 2013

Listing the fields of dreams

Back in the mad, bad old days when I worked on magazines for a company that seemed invincible but no longer exists, I had a theory, probably rubbish, that most mags had a maximum of about six people at any one time that they could put on the cover and get a guaranteed sale. It was based on the notion that in any specialist area - musical genres, blockbuster movies, football - that was about the number of acts that the entire readership would have an interest in. It was a rolling cast and as some dropped out, others arrived, but six was roughly the number.

If you strayed outside of the six, you were taking a risk with a commercial property. Yet the frequency of most magazines meant there were more covers than there were guaranteed bankers to put on them without resorting to the kind of trivial repetition that you see so often now (token bitchy comment, but nonetheless true).

One way around it was to come up with a 'list feature' - the hundred best this, the twenty sexiest that and so on. It was particularly popular at Christmas when there was nothing else going on, and if you gave it enough of a spin, it was pretty failsafe, especially if it was compiled by some sort of reader vote on the winner.

This week has proven the concept retains its catnip qualities, with Wisden announcing an 'All-Time Text XI' and Patrick Ferriday publishing Masterly Batting, a book that ranks the best Test hundreds ever made.

C'mon, admit it, you need to know who's there don't you... I did, and there's something about human nature that wants to see a list and then disagree with it (the first thing you learn about the list feature is that it is made to be disagreed with - it's the only way that it will achieve any sort of traction with the reader).

The point is, it's a trick, it's a trap... you're joining in a zero-sum game when you take up the argument. The Wisden All-Time Test team picks eleven from more than 2,600 people to have appeared in a Test match across 150 years of the Almanack's life. Masterly Batting selects 100 centuries from 3,649 scored by 697 players. The mathematical chances of agreeing with them are approaching those of winning the lottery, and that's before the emotional arena is approached.

Even the act of typing out the Test XI - Hobbs, Grace, Bradman (c), Tendulkar, Richards, Sobers, Knott (wk), Akram, Warne, Marshall, Barnes - has the fingers creeping towards other keys... (Hobbs - really? and Bradman, well he was no captain was he, and it's great that Richards is in but for me it's the wrong one because my love for B.A. is irrational, and does anyone still think Sobers was a better all-rounder than Kallis, and where are all the South Africans and New Zealanders and Sri Lankans, because surely Hadlee's a good shout isn't he and old Murali took a wicket or two, and what sort of conditions are these teams playing in anyway? Are Wisden seriously trying to contend that any judge worth their salt would pick Alan Knott over Adam Gilchrist, and as for Barnes with his dibbly dobblers on a modern track - cannon fodder, and even if he bowled on a greentop, well everyone on earth would rather face him than Thomson or Holding wouldn't they? And who was it that left out the man who made both the highest Test and first-class scores?) and so on, ad infinitum.

In Masterly Batting, Patrick Ferriday measures each hundred in ten categories: size, percentage of team score, speed, bowlers faced, the pitch, chances offered, match impact, series impact, compatibility of attack and conditions, and finally intangibles (a get out of jail card if ever there was one), and these are worthy measures. It's just that my favourite hundreds have little to do with any of those criteria, or at least they're tangential and not at the core of their appeal.

Would I have enjoyed Boycott's hundredth hundred any less if England hadn't won (at least I think they won - it doesn't matter now), or KP's 158 in 2005 any more had it been less manic and flukey and chanceless? What about all of those Steve Waugh tons when I loved him and hated him at the same time, and why did I get a lump in my throat when he hit that boundary from the last ball of the day at the SCG?

And yet none of those thoughts really detract from the nature of the Test XI or the best centuries, because they brought them back to me. I felt them once again, and that's a nice thing. In Masterly Batting, choosing the hundreds is actually secondary to the chance to write well about cricket and stand out a little on the shelves. Wisden had a couple of days' worth of headlines and they're always useful if the noble name is to survive and prosper for another century and a half.

But c'mon, really, did they even consider the fall-out if Bradman tried telling Grace where to stand...


4 comments:

Sumeet Gupta said...

Nicely summed up. I think it is a futile exercise to select an all-time XI. And Wisden made it worse by selecting Grace! Really?? What did they have before selecting this team??

John Halliwell said...

‘........and as for Barnes with his dibbly dobblers on a modern track - cannon fodder, and even if he bowled on a greentop, well everyone on earth would rather face him than Thomson or Holding wouldn't they?’

OB, I almost choked on my cornflakes when I read that. I think it’s the dismissive ‘....and as for Barnes...’ that had me muttering ‘What? Then ‘What? again. Then again…..I then regained composure and thought you might have something, but I doubted it. I wondered where to turn for an authoritative view; inevitably it had to be from someone unable to assess Barnes in a present-day context; the closest I could get was Arlott in 1963:

‘ The living legend that is Sydney Francis Barnes became ninety years old on 19 April 1963. Those who played with or against him, over a period of almost three normal cricketing lifetimes, had no doubt that he stood alone - the greatest bowler that ever lived.

More than six feet tall - he is still dominatingly erect at ninety - with high, wide, rugged shoulders, deep chest, long arms and strong legs, he was perfectly built to be a bowler. He made himself into a right-arm fast medium bowler with the accuracy, spin and resource of a slow bowler whose high delivery gave him a lift off the pitch that rapped the knuckles of the unwary and forced even the best batsmen to play him at an awkward height. He had a faster ball and a slower one, in a well concealed reserve, and the ability to bowl a yorker. He himself is content that he was essentially a spin bowler, that his movement through the air was, in modern technical language, swerve - obtained by spin - rather than swing, which derives from the ‘seam-up’ method. Certainly he made the ball move both ways through the air, and - with a first - and second finger application - he bowled the off-break and the leg-break. Indeed, he could bowl the googly at about slow-medium pace and where, in exceptional conditions, the pitch dictated it, he could be a fine slow bowler.

(One of Barnes’ finest bowling spells came in the 1911/12 series) On a perfect, hard Melbourne wicket, he produced his epic opening spell against a strong Australian batting side. Starting the bowling with F R Foster, he put out the first four Australian batsmen - Bardsley, Kellaway, Hill and Armstrong - for one run. He had Minnet’s wicket, too, and after eighty minutes, his figures were 11 overs, 7 maidens, 6 runs, 5 wickets.

Simply to see him bowl - and he was over sixty on the only occasion I ever watched him in action - was to make an instant impression of majesty, hostility and control. This was, without doubt, a born bowler, who lived to bowl. No batsman ever dared to to claim he was Barnes’s master. Asked which of them he found most difficult he answers ‘Victor Trumper’. Who next? ‘No one else ever troubled me.’

No cricketer who played with or against him has any doubt that Sydney Barnes was the greatest bowler the world has ever seen.’

(John Arlott covers much more than the extracts I’ve included)

So, OB, I don’t know where the truth lies, but I suspect Barnes’ dibbly dobblers were a class apart from any others.

bollytech keeda said...

Mothers day gift ideas 2015
Good Mothers day gift ideas
homemade mother's day gift ideas
Unique homemade mother's day gift ideas
homemade mother's day gifts 2015
mother's day gift ideas
mother's day gifts



Mothers day Quotes 2015
Mothers day Quotes 2015 From daughter
Mothers day Quotes from daughter
Mothers day Quotes 2015 from son
Mothers day Quotes 2015 from wife
Mothers day Quotes Messges Wishes
Mothers day Quotes 2015 from Daughter In Hindi
Mothers day Quotes 2015 from whatsapp Facebook status




cbse 12th class result declared
cbse 12th class result declared In May
cbse 12th class result
cbse 12th class result announced
cbse 12th class result reveal
cbse 12th class result




class 12 cbse result 2015
class 12 cbse result 2015 declared
class 12 cbse result 2015 declared In May
cbse 12th class result 2015
class 12 cbse result announced
class 12 cbse result 2015


terminator genisys 2015
Terminator genisys 2015 Trailer
Terminator genisys 2015 Release Date
Terminator genisys 2015 Trailer In HD
Terminator genisys 2015 torrent
Terminator genisys 2015 Full Movie Watch Online Free
Terminator genisys 2015 Full Movie In English
Terminator genisys 2015 Full Movie In HD

bollytech keeda said...

pepsi ipl 8 2015 live match streaming youtube
pepsi ipl 8 2015 live match streaming free
pepsi ipl 8 2015 matches highlights
pepsi ipl 8 2015 live telecast
ipl 8 live streaming 2015 hd
ipl 8 live streaming 2015 gocricket
ipl 8 live streaming 2015 webcric
pepsi ipl 8 2015 match schedule
ipl 8 2015 live streaming blogspot
watch ipl 8 2015 live streaming online
ipl 8 2015 live streaming low bandwidth
watch ipl 8 2015 live streaming free


fathers day quotes gift ideas 2015
hapy fathers day quotes gift ideas 2015
fathers day quotes gift ideas
fathers day quotes 2015
fathers day quotes In Hindi
fathers day quotes gift ideas 2015
homemade father's day gift ideas
homemade father's day gift ideas from toddler



fathers day poems 2015
fathers day poems
fathers day poems 2015 in spanish from daughter
father's day poems 2015 australia
fathers day poems from daughter
fathers day poems from son
fathers day poems In hindi
fathers day poems In english