Monday, 30 July 2012

Graeme Smith: the size and the shape

During the Oval Test, Shane Warne described Graeme Smith as 'a gentle soul'. Warnie had formed this unlikely view during the downtime the pair shared at Rajasthan Royals, and while they probably weren't nipping off together to recreate Lady Di's famous pose in front of the Taj Mahal just for japes, it was telling that one of cricket's uncompromising characters was prepared to accept another in such a way.

Everything about Smith's public persona mitigates against the notion, and it seemed even more incongruous while he undertook his umpteenth mighty blunting of England's bowlers, obscuring the stumps, blotting out hope, casting shade and spreading doubt. Iron-jawed, thin-lipped, unshaven, gazing at the world through the same sun-bound squint as Steve Waugh, he is both a prosaic destroyer and a technical enigma.

Like a giant Heath Robinson engine, Smith's batting shouldn't work. Recreated under scientific conditions with another player, it almost certainly  wouldn't. He has scored the bulk of his eight thousand plus Test match runs with half a bat for a start, his choking grip offering a closed face to the world. A right arm bowler pushing a delivery across Smith's ample bow and away towards the slips might find himself being driven anywhere from mid-on to backward square leg, the ball flying from a semi-visible slither of willow. However wide the cherry might be spearing, Smith's head will probably still be outside of it, his weight rolling across the crease behind, hence England's fleeting period of success against him when Matthew Hoggard brought the ball late and fast back into his pads.

The laundry list of shots Smith cannot hit is long, and even if he could cover drive, would anyone want to watch him do it? It's one of the great cosmic jokes that he is so often partnered with the symphonic Hashim Amla, the brutal orthodoxy of Kallis, the mercurial AB de Villiers.

Yet Smith has a daunting physicality that not even the Leviathan Kallis can match. He succeeds in part because of his scale. Cricket is a finely calibrated game, the size and weight of bat, ball and stumps, the length of the pitch, the distance to the boundary allow players of all sizes and various skills to compete. James Taylor at five feet four, can face Morne Morkel at six feet six, in a contest that few other arenas would allow. Scale, though, has its edges as Will Jefferson has demonstrated. Graeme Smith is on the right side of that edge, a man whose odd technique combines with his size and shape to offer a unique proposition. He has a brilliant eye - he must have to keep middling the ball with such a sharply angled bat - and by standing the way he does, he all but eliminates the target.

His approach offers a different psychological challenge to the bowler. He barely sees the stumps and he will be hit into odd areas often and deliberately. It's hard to practice for a batsman like Smith because there is no other batsman like Smith. And because he doesn't look like he should be able to bat, there is a certain tiny, rat-like corner of the brain that is affronted by an inability to dismiss him. There can be few opponents who frustrate England as often and for as long as Graeme Smith. The gentleness does not extend as far as the pitch. He is cracking them, bit by bit.


10 comments:

Cric Sloggers said...

Awesome. It is a joke when you see Smith and Amla bat together, one batting with elegance and another with pure brutality. Warnie sure did misjuge Smith, calling him "a gentle soul"!

SB Tang said...

Thanks for another great piece.

A couple of interesting points you raised are (coincidentally) discussed in a piece on Smith which I posted yesterday:

- Yup, Smith definitely is a “technical enigma” alright. “He stands (or, perhaps more accurately, squats) as proof, if any further was needed, of the enduring wisdom of Sir Donald Bradman’s philosophy on batting technique: ‘I experimented — worked out the pros and cons — and eventually decided not to change my [unconventional] natural grip. Throughout a long career my grip caused many arguments but I think it is sufficient to prove that any young player should be allowed to develop his own natural style providing he is not revealing an obvious error. A player is not necessarily wrong just because he is different.’”

- Yup, he “obscure[s] the stumps” alright. “By the time he actually plays the ball, his head is well outside his off-stump and he is covering his middle and off stumps with both his pads. His leg stump is at least partially exposed. This makes him a prime candidate to be bowled around his legs by a left-arm swing bowler. Indeed, an 18 year old Mohammad Amir dismissed Simon Katich — another obdurate left-handed leg-to-off shuffler — in that fashion at Headingley in July 2010. Fortunately for Smith, world-class-left-arm-swing-bowlers-who-aren’t-serving-five-year-bans-for-spot-fixing are about as easy to find as moral human beings in House Lannister.”

Here's a link to my full piece on Smith: http://astraightbat.wordpress.com/2012/07/30/graeme-smith-superglued-to-the-toilet-seat-and-flailing-to-get-off/

livescore said...

No doubt he is size in shape, he is great player and a legend in South African cricket and i will say he is lucky captain that Hashim Amila is there in his team and now he is showing responsibilities and proving as back bone of African batting line.

Ravi said...

Interesting! Smith is one of my favorite batsmen.

Imran MIS said...

Watch Sri Lanka vs Zimbabwe Live Stream ICC World Twnety20 1st Match Online Cricket On Pc>>>



http://sachin1tendulkar.blogspot.com/2012/09/watch-sri-lanka-vs-zimbabwe-live-stream.html

http://sachin1tendulkar.blogspot.com/2012/09/watch-sri-lanka-vs-zimbabwe-live-stream.html


http://sachin1tendulkar.blogspot.com/2012/09/watch-sri-lanka-vs-zimbabwe-live-stream.html


http://sachin1tendulkar.blogspot.com/2012/09/watch-sri-lanka-vs-zimbabwe-live-stream.html

livescore said...

No doubt Graeme Smith has size and shape and he is more then a cricketer. His physic is very impressive and attractive he looks like an athlete. He has impressive personality as well.

Pay per head said...

buddy I like your posts so much, they are very informative, but you should add some images too to make it even more appealing!

Rahul said...


Please take a look around and check out this website Sri Lanka Driver . You will find a lot of information about Sri Lanka especially about sight seeing tours you can do and about the way of travelling in Sri Lanka.

Rahul said...

Sri Lanka is in the ocean of the Indian subcontinent. But it is an independent country with its own sovereignty. Tropical island is small, but has a diverse geography and climate. A person who can travel to Sri Lanka Driver to any area of ??hot or cold fast pace to move within only six hours by car.

Rahul said...

A highly experienced driver/guide with over 25 years in the field of tourism, Bandara is well versed with the history, culture archeology and wildlife of Sri Lanka Driver .